Welcome Guest! YouRememberThat.com is 100% FREE & fast to join! Upload, comment, create your own profile and more!

Check our brand new site TheRetroSite , although YouRememberThat will remain for quite some time we expect this new site to be our new home. Click over and create your account on the new mobile friendly and flexible site today!
Dorothy Kilgallen as WML  Mystery Guest This is one of the more famous and memorable What's My Line mystery challenger segments. From February 5, 1961 regular WML panelist Dorothy Kilgallen, who had missed three weeks of shows due to illness, surprised her colleagues by being a mystery challenger!
Tags: Whats  My  Line  Dorothy  Kilgallen 
Added: 19th March 2009
Views: 2399
Posted By: Lava1964
Posted by: Lava1964 on 2009-03-19 
Too bad Bennett Cerf was on vacation that week and missed out on the surprise!
Posted by: Lava1964 on 2009-03-19 
Let's see now...

Bennett Cerf was a mystery challenger on the syndicated version of WML in 1968.

John Daly was famously the final mystery challenger on the CBS version in 1967.

Steve Allen was a mystery challenger on several occasions.

Fred Allen was a surprise mystery challenger when he was supposed to be home recuperating from an appendectomy.

Ernie Kovacs was a mystery challenger during his short stint as a semi-regular panelist.

Dorothy Kilgallen was the mystery challenger here.

Only Arlene Francis seemed to miss out on the fun of sitting opposite the WML panel!
Add A Comment
Sorry, guests can't post comments!